Your two 5's may be the same, but others will rate one a four. It is the cumulative rating that counts and I don't think there is a problem with the current 1 through 5
scale.
I renamed all the titles of coins in the BOT
gallery yesterday, the default order is by title. You can change your viewing sort order but if you leave the default, two coins of the same
type (with identical or similar titles) should be next to eachother or very close in the sort order. You shouldn't have to use
search to browse the BOT at all (but you can). For example, if
members start titles for
Roman Coins with
ROMAN, they will fall into the right order. I will periodically re-title entries to keep a logical sort order.
If you want to see all the
Athens tets, scroll until you find the coins starting with "GREEK,
Athens..." (some may be "GREEK,
Attica,
Athens...").
I will consider volunteer Admins for BOT. The responsibilities would be:
Periodically editing titles to keep a logical sort order for all the files.
Deleting coins with a rating below 4.1 and over 10 votes.
Posting a challenge notification on the boards (use a new
thread) when you notice two coins of the same
type, setting an end date for voting (maybe two weeks?).
Setting an end date for the challenge when a member posts their own challenge notification on the boards (again, maybe two weeks?)
Deleting the lower rated coin when enough votes make the results of a challenge clear (posted end date passed and at least 10 votes for each).
Really a simple system. It is meant only to be
good fun and to accumulate a beautiful
gallery of coins for everyone to enjoy.