Hi Jeff,
I've never used Gringgott's #2, though I do have a bag of it. However, I have used Gringgott's #1 quite a
bit. As I recall, #1 is better for long term soaks, while #2 is for short term soaking.
The instructions that came with #1 are very similar to what you found. What I would suggest is this: Take a container that is microwave-safe and boil two cups of distilled (DI) water. Get it very, very hot. Using some oven mitts, move the
still boiling water to a
work area, then mix in one table spoon of Gringgott's. Most of it will dissolve, but some will inevitably remain at the bottom. So much as I can tell this is harmless, but I wouldn't want the powder just sitting on top of coins either. Stir with a spoon and pour into another temperature safe
dish (plastic works
fine). Drop your coins in while the liquid is
still very hot, then let it cool off without a lid. Once it's cool, cover it.
Gringgott's #1 suggests 7-10 days of waiting, but #2 is for shorter term. I would think only a few days. You can probably do repeat cycles if you want, but you'll need to remake the solution each time and rinse the coins in DI water.
With #1, you will notice the solution start to turn blue-green after a while. Gringgott's is basically a specialty detergent/solvent, and I believe it works by creating an ionic environment that favors the dissolving of copper salts from the surface of the coin. DI water does the same thing, but perhaps the other components in Gringgott's provide something for the copper to bind in the solution to keep it dissolved - but I really can't be sure.
Regardless, don't expect anything too miraculous. It does genuinely
work, but it won't take a slug or low grade coin and make it high-end. The
quality of the starting product sets the
cap on what you will see. It doesn't seem to harm
patina, but there are never any guarantees there.
Happy Holidays,
C
Edit: I actually just searched for directions on the web, and happened to notice that Gringgott's number 2 isn't available on their website anymore. I'm not sure what to make of that, but perhaps it's temporarily unavailable.