Dr. Ilya Prokopov's Fake Ancient Coin Reports
  Worried About Fakes? All Items Purchased From Forum Are GUARANTEED AUTHENTIC For Eternity!!! Know The Coin OR Know The Dealer Has Expertise And A Guarantee Of Authenticity NEVER Buy From Any Seller On Our Notorious Fake Seller List!!! You DO NOT Need To Be An Expert To Collect Ancient Coins - Buy From Reputable Professional Dealers If You Don't Know The Coin Is Genuine - You MUST Know The Seller Is Reputable - OR DO NOT BUY!!! If You Want To Learn - Examine The Study Images Below And Join The Classical Numismatics Discussion Worried About Fakes? All Items Purchased From Forum Are GUARANTEED AUTHENTIC For Eternity!!! Please Visit Our Shop And Find A Coin You Love Today!!!

Home | Login | Album list | Last uploads | Last comments | Most viewed | Top rated | My Favorites | Search
Home > Fake Coin Reports > Fake Roman Imperial Coins: Crisis to Recovery: Maximinus I - Numerian: AD 235 - 284

Most viewed - Fake Roman Imperial Coins: Crisis to Recovery: Maximinus I - Numerian: AD 235 - 284
Aemil.jpg
Aemilian, Gold Aureus409 viewsAemilian, 253 AD. AV Aureus
Obv: IMP AEMILIANVS PIVS FEL AVG, laureate, draped and cuirassed bust of Aemilian right
Rev: APOL CONSERVAT, Apollo standing left, holding branch and leaning elbow on lyre.

offered for sale on ebay October 2008
maridvnvm
modern_aurelian_aureus.JPG
Aurelian, Aureus, Virtus Aug408 viewsObv:- IMP C M DOM AVRELIANVS P F AVG, Laureate cuirassed bust left
Rev:- VIRTVS AVG, Mars walking right holding spear and trophy, to right captive.
RIC 15 var. (an unlisted left facing version); 4.61 grams

Modern fake sold on German eBay as authentic for 825 EUR (Jan. 2006). According to the auction description the coin has "multiple tooth marks". This is a slightly better image than the example already in the Fake Reports.
postvmvs
e10671.jpg
Gordian I, Sestertius, RIC 14406 viewsObv: IMP CAES M ANT GORDIANVS AFR AVG
Bust: Laureate, draped and cuirassed bust right Rev: Rev: VIRTVS AVGG SC
Virtus standing left, leaning on shield, holding staff.
Diameter: 28-30mm
Ref: RIC 14, Cohen 15, Sear'88 2386

This has been on e-bay as both GI & GII
su8.JPG
Balbinus, Sestertius, RIC 19400 viewsObv: IMP CAES D CAE L BALBINVS AVG
Bust: Laureate, draped and cuirassed bust right
Rev: PROVIDENTIA DEORVM
Providentia standing left with cornucopia and wand pointed at globe at feet
Ref: RIC 19, Cohen 24, Sear 2404


FAKE, sold on Ebay as genuine.
su1.JPG
Otacilia Severa, Antoninianus, RIC 125c392 viewsObv: M OTACIL SEVERA AVG
Bust: Diademed, draped bust right on crescent
Rev: CONCORDIA AVGG
Concordia seated left with patera and cornucopiae
Ref: RIC 125c, Cohen 4
Bulgarian hand struck forgery.
wie723796.jpg
Balbinus, Antoninianus, RIC 12391 viewsObv: IMP CAES D CAE L BALBINVS AVG, Radiate, draped and cuirassed bust right.
Rev: PIETAS MVTVA AVGG, 2 hands clasping
Ref: RIC 12, Cohen 17.

For sale on eBay 01/29/2005 by Toronto Group, ID "babylonruniz".
Submitted by Maridvnvm
1 commentsmaridvnvm
m811[2].jpg
Nigrinian, antoninianus387 viewsNigrinian, antoninianus
MaxThrax.jpg
Maximinus, Denarius, RIC 3383 viewsObv:- IMP MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG, laureate, draped and cuirassed bust right.
Rev:- P M TR P II COS P P, Maximinus standing between two legionary standards. Ref:- RIC 3, RSC 55

The top example was for sale on ebay as genuine September 2005 the bottom example is from the ancients.info black gallery.

Modern Bulgarian Fake- "Lipanoff" studio, #107 in Prokopov's booklet

Submitted by maridvnvm
maridvnvm
01_120.jpg
PHILIP I383 viewsAR Аntoninianus, 20/20 mm; 4,273 g; 7h.
Obv. IMP M IVL PHILIPPVS AVG Radiate bust of Philippus to r.
Rev. SAECVLARES AVGG / COS III Column.
Struck. Die-engraver "Lipanoff Studio"
Published: Sofia 2004, no.120
Ilya Prokopov
PACATIANUS.jpg
Pacatianus, Antoninianus, RIC 6382 viewsObv: IMP TI CL MAR PACATIANVS AVG
Bust: Radiate, draped bust right
Rev: ROMAE AETER AN MILL ET PRIMO
Rome seated left holding Victory and spear
Weight: 6.63 g
Die rotation: 130° (Other Pacatianus examined have a die rotation of around 157°)
Ref: RIC 6, RSC 7

Sold on Ebay as authentic coin. Questioned by Forvm members, later determined by bpmurphy to be modern forgery, with the following observations:

My findings:

1) The coin is a cast. There are no flow lines on the coin, the lettering and details are all weak. At 9:00 on the reverse there are traces of a flan crack, but the flan is not cracked, it is a remnant from the host coin. There is a die break on the obverse at about 10:30 that extends from the radiate crown, through the lettering across the border of dots and to the edge of the flan. The apparent porosity on the reverse and around the protrait is not porosity but roughness from the casting.

2) the "coin" weighs 6.63 gm which is too heavy for this issue, much heavier than other recorded specimens. Pacatians typically weigh between 3.2 and 4.5 gms.

3) The toning is fake and rubs off with my fingers.

4) The "coin" appears to have been cast in a metal other than silver. I didn't do a specific gravity to be certain but it doesn't ring like silver should.

5) The "coin" is of even thickness all the way around. Struck coins tend to have a thicker side and thinner side depending on the angle of strike.

6) There are traces of a scratch on the reverse from the edge at 6:00 to the middle of the coin that appears to have been copied from the original.

The piece is interesting to me though, as both dies can be accounted for on other Pacatians. This is apparently a cast of an authentic coin that I was not familiar with and I have added this to my photo file, with a note of course that this coin is a cast.

Bluefish
Probo_Antoniniano_RESTITVTOR_Remoneda_Omni_May_2010.jpg
Probus, Antoninianus382 viewsSpecimen manufactured by micro-fusion (Lost-wax casting).
Picture facilitated by Remoneda in the Spanish Forum OMNI, May 2010.

AE Antoninianus, Cyzicus mint, 3º Emission, 280-281 A.D.

Obv: IMP CM AVR PROBVS PF AVG, radiate, draped and cuirassed bust right.
Rev: RESTITVTOR EXERCITI, Probus standing right, receiving globe from Jupiter standing left, each holding scepter. T in center field, MCXXI in exerge.
RIC Vb Cyzicus #909; Cohen #514var (Bust)
mdelvalle
Probus.jpg
Probus, Antoninianus, RIC 776 Bust Type G380 viewsObv: IMP C M AVR PROBVS P F AVG
Bust: Radiate, helmeted, cuirassed bust left holding spear and shield
Rev: SOLI INVICTO,
Sol in spread quadriga, clouds beneath
Delta in centre field, XXI in exe.
Ref: RIC 776 Bust Type G

The top photo is the Bulgarian replica as originally sold. The bottom photo is how an example of this type was offered on eBay.
Balbinus.jpg
Balbinus, Antoninianus, RIC 10375 viewsObv: IMP CAES D CAE L BALBINVS AVG, Radiate, draped and cuirassed bust right.
Rev: CONCORDIA AVGG, 2 hands clasping
Ref: RIC 10, RSC 3, Sear 2394

Modern Bulgarian Fake- "Lipanoff" studio #112/A in Prokopov's booklet

Submitted by maridvnvm
maridvnvm
pupi-amor.jpg
Pupienus, Antoninianus, RIC 9b369 viewsObv: IMP CAES PVPIEN MAXIMVS AVG
Bust: Radiate, draped and cuirassed bust right
Rev: AMOR MVTVVS AVGG
Clasped right hands
Ref: RIC 9b, RSC 2, Sear'88 2410

Toronto Group forgery

You can never condemn a coin just because it is perfectly centered on a larger than usual flan, but it is a reason to give it a close look.

On this coin the edge is much too sharp compared to the apparent wear on the rest of the coin.
whitetd49
Aureliano_Antoniniano_ORIENS_AVG_Remoneda__Imperio_ene_2012.jpg
Aurelian, Antoninianus369 viewsMultiple specimens manufactured by Remoneda (Lost-wax casting).
Shown in the Spanish Forum Imperio-Numismatico in Jan/2012

AE antoninianus, Ticinum mint, second officinae (workshop), struck 270 - 275 A.D.

Obv: IMP C AVRELIANVS AVG, radiate and cuirassed bust right.
Rev: ORIENS AVG, Sol advancing left raising right hand and holding globe in left, two captives at feet, SXXT in exergue.
RIC Va Ticinum #151
mdelvalle
gord3_modern.JPG
Gordian III, denarius, Emperor on Horseback, RIC 81366 viewsIMP GORDIANVS PIVS FEL AVG, laureate bust right, draped and cuirassed / P M TR P III COS P P, Gordian riding horse left, holding hand high in salute and scepter. 17-18 mm, 3.4 grams.

Modern. Sold as genuine on eBay (Feb. 2006) for $63.00 by 'borovez', who sells a mixture of genuine and fake coins. Another example (from same die pair) sold on the Polish auction site Allegro.pl as a reproduction.
postvmvs
01_117.jpg
GORDIAN III361 viewsAR Аntoninianus, 20/21 mm; 4,357 g; 6h.
Obv. IMP GORDIANVS PIVS FEL AVG Radiate bust of Gordian to r.
Rev. AEQVITAS AVGG Ecvitas standing to l., holding cornucopia and a set of scales.
Struck. Die-engraver "Lipanoff Studio"
Published: Sofia 2004, no.117
I. Prokopov
Ilya Prokopov
db_1_b.jpg
Trajan Decius, Denarius, RIC 21b359 viewsObv:– IMP C M Q TRAIANVS DECIVS AVG, Radiate, draped, cuirassed bust right
Rev:– PANNONIAE, The two Pannoniae, each holding a standard, standing half left but looking in opposite directions
Minted in Rome. A.D. 249 - 251
Ref:– RIC 21b, RCV88 2699. RSC 86 .

The top example was for sale on ebay as genuine September 2005 the bottom example is from the ancients.info black gallery.

Modern Bulgarian Fake- "Lipanoff" studio, #126 in Prokopov's booklet

Submitted by maridvnvm
maridvnvm
Gordianus III.JPG
Gordian III, Antoninianus, RIC - Unknown356 viewsObv: IMP GORDIANVS PIVS FEL AVG
Bust: Radiate and draped bust right, seen from rear
Rev: Not shown
Ref: Unknown

Cast Forgery
1 comments
rup-gordii-441.JPG
Gordianus II sestertius Romae Aeternae353 viewsThis Gordian II sestertius, rev. Romae Aeternae, is already on the boards, but here's a much more dangerous (because diligently patinated) specimen. Note, however, the weak and poorly shaped letters on both sides. Sold on German Ebay in December 2005 for 441€ by a seller who was unaware of the fake and who otherwise sells good coins. Let's not forget it happens to each of us!

submitted by rupert
Rupert
rup-des66-carin-100.jpg
Carinus Caesar Aureus, Pax Aeterna343 viewsSold as genuine on German Ebay for 100 Euros. The poor style portrait is a giveaway already.

submitted by rupert
Rupert
collage1.jpg
Gordian III with Laetitia reverse343 viewsObv: IMP GORDIANVS PIVS FEL AVG
Rev: LAETITIA PIVS AVG N
Diameter: 19.4mm
Weight: 2.9gr
Seller: Cataract City Coins

A heavy silver or nickel plating over a cast copper core. Edges polished smooth revealing copper color. Sold as "Superb AU" denarius.
saholz
NEW-4.jpg
Gordian II Sestertius343 viewsCondemned as fake by Forum staff.Mark Z
GordianIII.jpg
GORDIAN III, (238 - 244)340 viewsAR Antoninianus
Obv. IMP GORDIANVS PIVS FEL AVG. Rad. bust r.
Rev: AETER NITATI AVG. Sol stg., holding globe and whip.
Cast, “Blagoevgrad Studio”.
Ilya Prokopov
1224 files on 51 page(s) 2

All coins are guaranteed for eternity