Dr. Ilya Prokopov's Fake Ancient Coin Reports
Forum Ancient Coins' Services for the Classical Numismatics Community

 


Category Albums Files
Fake Coin ReportsReports of modern replicas and forgeries of ancient coins submitted by FORVM's Classical Numismatic Discussion Board members. Please join our discussion board and report fake ancient coins here. FORVM recommends buying ancient coins only from reputable dealers. ALL COINS PURCHASED FROM FORVM ANCIENT COINS ARE GUARANTEED FOR ETERNITY. If you must purchase from an unknown seller, we recommend looking for the type here first. The search function may be useful for finding a specific ruler, city or type. FORVM will screen these reports and correct any errors we detect, however, any discussion board member may submit a report. It is possible that a genuine coin could be listed here in error. Except for known fraudulent regular sellers of fakes, do not include the names of sellers in reports. DO NOT POST COINS HERE TO ASK IF THEY ARE FAKE - USE THE DISCUSSION BOARD.
10 7860
Greek Archaic and Classical


Philip11.jpg

1321 files, last one added on Feb 28, 2010

Hellenistic Period


Hist15.jpg

972 files, last one added on Mar 13, 2010

Celtic and Barbaric


FAKE_Thasos.jpg

205 files, last one added on Mar 03, 2010

Roman Republic


FAKE_1.jpg

669 files, last one added on Mar 03, 2010

Roman Imperial


MThrax.jpg

4141 files, last one added on Mar 14, 2010

Roman Provincial (Greek Imperial)


FAKE_Caracalla_4.jpg

138 files, last one added on Mar 03, 2010

Byzantine


Byzantine.JPG

139 files, last one added on Feb 11, 2010

Other


HST_.jpg

135 files, last one added on Mar 07, 2010

Stolen or Lost Coin Reports


postumus.jpg

Report coins that have been lost or stolen here (not fakes). You must include your username in the description and explain the loss or theft. If you see a coin reported as lost or stolen, please inform the owner.

56 files, last one added on Jan 20, 2010

Modern Fake Dies


byzantine_coin_mold_sale_on_ebay_2_2010.jpg

84 files, last one added on Feb 12, 2010

10 albums on 1 page(s)

Study ImagesExamine these images and read the descriptions to learn how to identify modern forgeries of ancient coins. Discussion board members please add images of study value and describe the characteristics that indicate the coin is a fake.
10 547
Evidence of Casting (Type Originally Struck)


Maximi.jpg

Pitting, filled cracks, field dips, edge seams, filing, soft features, lack of detail, ghost images...

88 files, last one added on Mar 07, 2010

Style Deviations


Gord_Medallion.jpg

Deviations from subtle to strange, forgers rarely get style right...

7 files, last one added on Oct 06, 2008

Evidence of Modern Tool Use to Cut Dies


P1100565_(1).JPG

Machine made dies...

23 files, last one added on Dec 23, 2009

Fabric Deviations


Julian 5.jpg

Wrong metal, wrong size, no edge cracks for a type that always has them, strange shape for the type...

11 files, last one added on Oct 22, 2007

Identifying the Work of Known Forgers


39~2.jpg

Slavey, Lipanoff, Becker, Christodoulos, the Black Sea hoard, the Toronto Group...

250 files, last one added on Oct 20, 2009

Other Indications of Forgery


P1100884.JPG

31 files, last one added on Jan 26, 2010

Tooling


Tooling2.jpg

A tooled coin is not a forgery, but it is a fake.

80 files, last one added on Oct 08, 2009

Artificial Patinas


kanites.jpg

Not every coin with an artificial patina is a forgery, but it is an indicator. In any case an artificial patina is a fake patina.

33 files, last one added on Feb 08, 2010

Evidence of Pressing


EdgePress1.JPG

Machine pressed vs. hand struck.

8 files, last one added on Oct 06, 2009

Fantasy Coins


Odessos~1.jpg

Fantasy coins are modern creations made to look like ancient coins, but do not copy a type that actually exists.

16 files, last one added on Mar 03, 2010

10 albums on 1 page(s)

AntiquitiesReports of small fake "antiquities."
2 47
Ancient


Fibula_(Horse).JPG

33 files, last one added on Mar 08, 2010

Medieval


ITB_25.jpg

14 files, last one added on Jan 15, 2010

2 albums on 1 page(s)

8454 files in 22 albums and 3 categories with 822 comments viewed 852844 times

Last additions
MThrax.jpg
MThrax.jpgMaximinus I Thrax (AD 235–238). 4 viewsAR Denarius, AD 235.
Obv. IMP MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG, laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right.
Rev. P M TR P P P, emperor standing facing in military attire, head left, raising right hand and holding inverted spear, standard on each side.
BMCRE 11. RIC 1. RSC 46.
Struck, "Anton Tomov Collection", Sofia.
Ilya ProkopovMar 14, 2010
17~5.jpg
17~5.jpgAugustus (27 BC-AD 14).2 viewsAR Denarius, Lugdunum mint, struck 15-13 BC.
Obv. AVGVSTUS DIVI F/ Bare head right.
Rev. IMP X, Bull butting right.
RIC 167a, RSC 137, BMC 451
Cast.
Ilya ProkopovMar 14, 2010
Macrinus~2.jpg
Macrinus~2.jpgMacrinus, AD 217–2183 viewsAR Denarius,
Obv. IMP C M OPEL SEV MACRINVS AVG, laureate, cuirassed bust of Macrinus right, with short beard.
Rev. PONTIF MAX TR P II COS II P P, Securitas standing facing, head left, legs crossed and arm resting on short column, holding vertical scepter in right hand and shorter transverse scepter in left hand.
Struck, "Anton Tomov Collection" Sofia.
1 commentsIlya ProkopovMar 13, 2010
DSCast.jpg
DSCast.jpgDomitia, wife of Domitian1 viewsAR Denarius, Struck 82-83 AD.
Obv. DOMITIA AVGVSTA IMP DOMIT, Draped bust right.
Rev. DIVVS CAESAR IMP DOMITIANI F, Infant seated left on globe with arms open; seven stars in field.
RIC II 213 (Domitian); BMCRE 63 (Domitian); BN 71 (Domitian); RSC 11.
Cast, “Dimitrovgrad Studio”.
Ilya ProkopovMar 13, 2010
Hist15.jpg
Hist15.jpgHISTIAIA, isl. of Euboia. 3rd-2nd c. B.C.1 viewsAR Tetrobol.
Obv. Wreathed head of nymph Histiaia r.
Rv. Nymph seated r. on stern of galley
Cast.
Ilya ProkopovMar 13, 2010
13~5.jpg
13~5.jpgAugustus (27 BC-AD 14). 5 viewsAR Denarius, ca. 18-17/16.
Obv. Bare head right, no legend.
Rev. AVGVSTVS, capricorn right, holding globe and rudder, cornucopiae above back.
RIC 126 (R2). RSC 21. RCV 1592.
Cast
Ilya ProkopovMar 11, 2010
Fibula_(Horse).JPG
Fibula_(Horse).JPGFibula (Horse)2 viewsAncient bronze fibula, cast, artificial patina.Ilya ProkopovMar 08, 2010
Fibula_(Mix).JPG
Fibula_(Mix).JPGFibula (Fantastic animal)4 viewsAncient bronze fibula, artificial patina.Ilya ProkopovMar 08, 2010
Balance2.jpg
Balance2.jpgBalance22 viewsAncient bronze balance, artificial patina.Ilya ProkopovMar 08, 2010
Maximi.jpg
Maximi.jpgGalerius Maximianus, 305-3118 viewsAR Medallion
Obv. GAL.MAXIMIANVS.AVG.VII.CONSS, laureate and cuirassed bust right, holding globe in his r. hand.
Rev. IOVIS CONSE RVATOR AVGG, Jupiter stg. l., holding long scepter end thunderbolt, eagle holding wreath at feet. In ex.: .S.M.S.D.
Cast from Slavey’s prototype.
Ilya ProkopovMar 07, 2010
Maximus~0.jpg
Maximus~0.jpgMaximus, Caesar, AD 235-2381 viewsAR Denarius, AD 236-238
Obv. MAXIMVS CAES GERM, draped bust right.
Rev. PRINC IVVENTVTIS, Maximus standing left, holding baton and spear, two standards behind him
RIC 3; RSC 10; RCV 8406.
Struck, “Lipanoff Studio”.
Collection: Anton Tomov, Sofia
Ilya ProkopovMar 07, 2010
Valens~0.jpg
Valens~0.jpgVALENS, 364-3781 viewsAE 3
Obv. CN VALENS PF AVG, Pearl-diademed, draped, and cuirassed bust right.
Rev. SECVRITA…BLICAE, Victory adv. l., in ex.: SMH
Struck. Made of copper, artificial patina.
Ilya ProkopovMar 07, 2010
HST_.jpg
HST_.jpgDollar (Truman)2 viewsMade of iron, silver plated.
Struck - Chinese fake. Positive on magnet test.
Ilya ProkopovMar 07, 2010
1840.jpg
1840.jpgDollar 18402 viewsMade of iron, silver plated.
Struck - Chinese fake. Positive on magnet test.
Ilya ProkopovMar 07, 2010
2020b.jpg
2020b.jpgConstantine I as Caesar3 viewsFake argenteus, copying RIC VI 638. Offered on Ebay 6 March 2010 by Bulgarian seller. Another example posted on Forum Fake Reports, but erroneously posted as "Constantine II Caesar, 316 – 337 ? siliqua" bupchurchMar 06, 2010
Caracalla~1.jpg
Caracalla~1.jpgCaracalla 198-217. 5 viewsAR Denar
Obv. ANTONIVS PIVS AVG GERM, Laur. bust r.
Rev. FIDEI EXE(R) CITVS, Fides stg. l.,holding two standarts
Struck, “Lipanoff Studio”.
Collection: Anton Tomov, Sofia
Ilya ProkopovMar 05, 2010

 

   

 
Catalog Board NumisWiki Auctions Gallery Fakes All