Dr. Ilya Prokopov's Fake Ancient Coin Reports
Forum Ancient Coins' Services for the Classical Numismatics Community

 


Category Albums Files
Fake Coin ReportsReports of modern replicas and forgeries of ancient coins submitted by FORVM's Classical Numismatic Discussion Board members. Please join our discussion board and report fake ancient coins here. FORVM recommends buying ancient coins only from reputable dealers. ALL COINS PURCHASED FROM FORVM ANCIENT COINS ARE GUARANTEED FOR ETERNITY. If you must purchase from an unknown seller, we recommend looking for the type here first. The search function may be useful for finding a specific ruler, city or type. FORVM will screen these reports and correct any errors we detect, however, any discussion board member may submit a report. It is possible that a genuine coin could be listed here in error. Except for known fraudulent regular sellers of fakes, do not include the names of sellers in reports. DO NOT POST COINS HERE TO ASK IF THEY ARE FAKE - USE THE DISCUSSION BOARD.
10 11488
Greek Archaic and Classical


alex1.jpg

2058 files, last one added on May 21, 2012

Hellenistic Period


Cast.jpg

1358 files, last one added on Apr 28, 2012

Celtic and Barbaric


8266D.jpg

311 files, last one added on Jan 23, 2012

Roman Republic


002b.jpg

919 files, last one added on Apr 28, 2012

Roman Imperial


Faustina_Jun.jpg

5809 files, last one added on May 18, 2012

Roman Provincial (Greek Imperial)


Picture_8~1.png

207 files, last one added on Feb 26, 2012

Byzantine


8386D.jpg

222 files, last one added on Jan 30, 2012

Other


image01056.jpg

353 files, last one added on May 20, 2012

Stolen or Lost Coin Reports


50076q00.jpg

Report coins that have been lost or stolen here (not fakes). You must include your username in the description and explain the loss or theft. If you see a coin reported as lost or stolen, please inform the owner.

67 files, last one added on Apr 26, 2011

Modern Fake Dies


Mehmed_V.jpg

184 files, last one added on Mar 09, 2012

10 albums on 1 page(s)

Study ImagesExamine these images and read the descriptions to learn how to identify modern forgeries of ancient coins. Discussion board members please add images of study value and describe the characteristics that indicate the coin is a fake.
10 1026
Evidence of Casting (Type Originally Struck)


Philip_II_Cast.jpg

Pitting, filled cracks, field dips, edge seams, filing, soft features, lack of detail, ghost images...

110 files, last one added on May 18, 2012

Style Deviations


AR_Medallion.jpg

Deviations from subtle to strange, forgers rarely get style right...

8 files, last one added on Nov 17, 2011

Evidence of Modern Tool Use to Cut Dies


mashine.JPG

Machine made dies...

27 files, last one added on Jan 06, 2012

Fabric Deviations


SilverPlated.JPG

Wrong metal, wrong size, no edge cracks for a type that always has them, strange shape for the type...

13 files, last one added on Aug 17, 2010

Identifying the Work of Known Forgers


MG9116.jpg

Slavey, Lipanoff, Becker, Christodoulos, the Black Sea hoard, the Toronto Group...

493 files, last one added on Dec 15, 2011

Other Indications of Forgery


SyraDeca.jpg

52 files, last one added on Feb 27, 2012

Tooling


Julia_m_.JPG

A tooled coin is not a forgery, but it is a fake.

84 files, last one added on Mar 23, 2012

Artificial Patinas


Immagine1.jpg

Not every coin with an artificial patina is a forgery, but it is an indicator. In any case an artificial patina is a fake patina.

46 files, last one added on Jun 09, 2011

Evidence of Pressing


img_2014.jpg

Machine pressed vs. hand struck.

11 files, last one added on Aug 07, 2010

Fantasy Coins


Augusto_Julio_Cesar_Denario_Fantasia.jpg

Fantasy coins are modern creations made to look like ancient coins, but do not copy a type that actually exists.

182 files, last one added on Jan 09, 2012

10 albums on 1 page(s)

AntiquitiesReports of small fake "antiquities."
2 133
Ancient


Hermes.jpg

109 files, last one added on May 14, 2012

Medieval


PendantMed.jpg

24 files, last one added on May 14, 2012

2 albums on 1 page(s)

12647 files in 22 albums and 3 categories with 852 comments viewed 1440470 times

Last additions
alex1.jpg
alex1.jpgAlexander the Great, silver tetradrachm, cast fake8 viewsAlexander the Great, silver tetradrachm, cast fake.
Size: 26mm
Weight: 11.8g
bronzematMay 21, 2012
alex3.jpg
alex3.jpgPtolemaic Kingdom, silver Tetradrachm - Cast Fake14 viewsPtolemaic Kingdom, silver tetradrachm, obvious cast.
Size: 26mm
Weight: 10.6g
bronzematMay 21, 2012
alex2.jpg
alex2.jpgAlexander the Great, silver tetradrachm, cast fake12 viewsAlexander the Great, silver tetradrachm, cast fake.
Size: 24mm
Weight: 11g
bronzematMay 21, 2012
image01056.jpg
image01056.jpgItaly.Sicily.Messina.Roger II (1105-1154) 10 viewsAV Multiple tari.
Two identical gold coins,obtained with the same mold, used in the lost wax casting. different weigth 1,79g-1,58g.
Offered by Italian auction house in may 2012.
cerniecoMay 20, 2012
saluto_lanz.jpg
saluto_lanz.jpgItaly Naples Charles d'Anjou. 1266-128513 viewsAV Saluto d'oro. The reverse is identical to one of the dies used to produce another coin by me reported as fake.
Offered for sale by a German auction house in june 2012.
cerniecoMay 18, 2012
saluto_ebay.jpg
saluto_ebay.jpgItaly Naples Charles d'Anjou. 1266-128516 viewsAV Saluto d'oro Weight:4,43 diameter:21
for sale on eBay as a perfect reproduction
cerniecoMay 18, 2012
Thrace_Istros_1_opt.jpg
Thrace_Istros_1_opt.jpgTHRACE Istros AR Trihemiobol, SNGCop 200, Alternating Heads8 viewsOBV: Two facing male heads, the right inverted
REV: ISTPIH, sea-eagle left, grasping dolphin with talons, AP monogram below dolphin
1.65g
LegatusMay 18, 2012
Philip_II_Cast.jpg
Philip_II_Cast.jpgPhilip II9 viewsAR Tetradrachm
Cast
Ilya ProkopovMay 18, 2012
Faustina_Jun.jpg
Faustina_Jun.jpgFaustina Junior. Augusta, AD 147-175. 5 viewsAR Denarius
Obv. FAVSTINA AVGVSTA
Rev. FECVNDITAS
Cast.
Ilya ProkopovMay 18, 2012
Ainos2.jpg
Ainos2.jpgAinos 5 c. BC5 viewsAR Tetradrachm,
Obv. Head of Hermes to right, wearing close-fitting petasos.
Rev. ΑEΝΙON Goat standing to right, all within incuse square.
Pressed.
Ilya ProkopovMay 18, 2012
Pertinax.jpg
Pertinax.jpgPertinax, ar denarius11 viewsCast. Seller"machthappy", almost all coins are fakes.Amir HMay 16, 2012
Aleksander.jpg
Aleksander.jpgAlexander III, AR tetradrachm13 viewsCast. Seller"machthappy", almost all coins are fakes.Amir HMay 16, 2012
AELIUS.jpg
AELIUS.jpgAelius, sestertius.14 viewsSestertius / Sesterz/ AELIUS SELTENHEIT RARR !

Aelius that need nose correction.
Ugly fake.
Amir HMay 14, 2012
PendantMed.jpg
PendantMed.jpgEncoplion6 viewsCast, bronze medieval bipartite cross pendant (Crucifix). The encolpion composed of two uniform halves and hinged at the top and bottom. Fake green patina. This cross was sold as original.Ilya ProkopovMay 14, 2012
1869_100_Fr_copy.jpg
1869_100_Fr_copy.jpgNapoleon III20 views100 francs, 1869 - foure.Ilya ProkopovMay 14, 2012
Hermes.jpg
Hermes.jpgHermes19 viewsBronze, 13.15 mm; casting is made from an original statuette. From this mold made multiple copies. The patina in many cases seems reliable. This figurine was sold as original.
Ilya ProkopovMay 14, 2012

 

   

 
Catalog Board NumisWiki Auctions Gallery Fakes All